Glen & Stephen Thistlewood
Carnival Glass Worldwide
  • Home
  • Patterns, Colours, Shapes
  • Carnival Gallery
  • Books, e-books

Fenton's April Showers vases


​The appearance of the April Showers pattern has been described in a number of eloquent and visually evocative ways:


- "the syrup drips around the edge of a Tate and Lyle can" (Tate and Lyle is very well known in the UK, especially for its "Golden Syrup", a sort of light molasses).

- "the bubbles in carbonated soft drink" (soda) - Bill Edwards.

- "a cascade of drops and ribs on an irregular 'rain on the window in a black and white Joan Crawford movie' manner" - Ray Notley.

Each conjures up a mental image which, whilst being a useful aid to identification, has the drawback that such descriptions can mean different things to different people. That means we should also look at the physical characteristics of the vase.

What to look for

​
A clear physical identifier was described by vase expert Joan Doty: "April Showers vases have nine vertical panels, each ending with a subtle scallop at the bottom of the vase. These nine panels are filled with “streams of raindrops,” actually small hobs".

The detailed picture below (of the bottom part of the vase) shows these semi-circular scallops very clearly. They can become less distinct the more the vase has been swung, but they are always present on April Showers.
April Showers
Subtle semi-circular scallops around the bottom of the vase

​Next, consider the size - not the height, but the base diameter. In height, April Showers vases are generally found from around 5 inches up to a massively swung 13 inches* but there is only one base diameter for April Showers - 3½ inches.

​
* scarce examples are known at 4
¼ inches (completely unswung) and 13¾ inches in height.
April Showers
April Showers, blue. Courtesy Joan Doty

Height

Height may not help the identification of April Showers, especially when the vase has been swung and the pattern of small hobs has been stretched out, but such a great variation in height that was achieved by the glassmakers has made April Showers vases a firm favourite with collectors.


Here are four April Showers vases (courtesy of Seeck Auctions).

They show how the hobs lose their definition and change the look of the pattern when the vases were swung.


April Showers
Height 5½ inches, green
April Showers
Height 10 inches, amethyst
April Showers
Height 11 inches, amethyst
April Showers
Height 13 inches, blue
The above pictures also illustrate a couple of other very noteworthy features of April Showers vases. Firstly, many of them (but not all) have a "drapery style" interior pattern called Peacock Tail (like Fenton's regular Peacock Tail pattern). The green vase on the left shows it to good effect, but the pattern can be far less easy to see on highly swung vases. Secondly, the vase third from the left has a tightly crimped top edge which gives it a distinctly different appearance. April Showers vases with this type of top edge treatment seem to be more of a minority when compared to the more usual ruffled top.
​
Identification and the "Look-alikes"

From time to time, Fenton's April Showers vases seem to cause difficulty in identifying them, and in distinguishing them from other fairly similar vases such as Fenton's Rustic and Northwood's Tree Trunk. 
Just as with April Showers, the unswung or lightly swung versions of Rustic and Tree Trunk shown the pattern elements very clearly, elements that are harder to see once the vase has been swung. The pictures below of Standard sized vases, courtesy of Seeck Auctions, show the differences.
Rustic
Rustic 6 inches, marigold
Rustic
Rustic 11 inches, green
Tree Trunk
Tree Trunk 6 inches, green
Picture
Tree Trunk 10 inches, purple



This guide on the right should make identification easier!



Rustic, Fenton

Rustic is made up of rows of clearly defined hobs that are evenly spaced around the vase. Even when it has been swung, the rows of hobs are usually fairly easy to make out.

Unlike April Showers (which was only made in one base size), there are three base sizes for Rustic: Standard, 3 to 3¼ inches; Midsize / Midsize Variant, 4 to 4¼ inches; and Funeral, 5 to 5¼ inches.

Tree Trunk, Northwood

The Tree Trunk pattern has been described as "bark-like" and "tadpoles", and it is perhaps the tadpoles description that highlights the most defining characteristic of this pattern - the small semi-circles or squiggles between the hobs.

Tree Trunk was made in four base sizes: Standard, 3⅜ to 3¾ inches; Midsize, 4¾ inches; Midsize Variant, 3¾ inches; and Funeral 5¼ inches.

With grateful thanks to Joan Doty for the invaluable information on the base sizes of these vases.

April Showers vase
Originally published in 1989.
Copyright © 2023 by G&S Thistlewood and the individual authors and contributors where named. Protected under all applicable international laws and all rights are reserved. No image, text, or any part thereof may be copied, shared or transmitted to others without permission from the Copyright holders. Information herein may not be posted or made available, in whole or in part, on any website, social media site, FTP site, electronic bulletin board, newsgroup, or their equivalent.